Combined Case Information: 61415 & 61415-COA
Short Caption:	VAILE VS. VAILE C/W 62797	Court:	Supreme Court & Court of Appeals
Consolidated:	61415*, 62797	Related Case(s):	36969, 37082, 51981, 52244, 52457, 52593, 53687, 53798, 55396, 55446, 55911, 60502, 61321, 61415-COA, 61626, 62797, 62797-COA, 68715, 77070
Lower Court Case(s):	Clark Co. - Eighth Judicial District - D230385	Classification:	Civil Appeal - General - Proper Person
Disqualifications:		Case Status:	Remittitur Issued/Case Closed
Replacement:		Panel Assigned:	En Banc
To SP/Judge:		SP Status:
Oral Argument:		Oral Argument Location:
Submission Date:	09/22/2016	How Submitted:	By Order

+ Party Information
Role	Party Name	Represented By
Appellant	Robert Scotlund Vaile	In Proper Person
Respondent	Cisilie A. Porsboll	Marshal S. Willick (Willick Law Group)
Respondent	Cisilie A. Vaile	Marshal S. Willick (Willick Law Group)

Docket Entries
Date	Type	Description	Pending?	Document
08/06/2012	Filing Fee	Filing Fee due for Appeal.
08/06/2012	Notice of Appeal Documents	Filed Notice of Appeal/Proper Person Pilot Program. Filed certified copy of proper person notice of appeal.		12-24703
08/06/2012	Notice/Outgoing	Issued Notice to Pay Supreme Court Filing Fee. No action will be taken on this matter until filing fee is paid. Due Date: 10 days.		12-24705
08/09/2012	Notice of Appeal Documents	Filed Documents from District Court Clerk - Civil Cover Sheet (SEALED).
08/13/2012	Filing Fee	Filing Fee Paid. $250.00 from Robert Vaile. Check no. 1367.
08/13/2012	Case Status Update	Pilot Program Civil Appeals. Order and documents mailed to proper person appellant. Civil proper person transcript request form due: 15 days. Civil proper person appeal statement due: 40 days.
08/15/2012	Motion	Filed Proper Person Motion to Defer Payment of Cost Bond and to Allow Full Briefing on Appeal.		12-25685
08/15/2012	Transcript Request	Filed Civil Proper Person Transcript Request Form.		12-25686
08/23/2012	Motion	Filed Opposition to "Motion to Defer Payment of Cost Bond and Motion to Allow Full Briefing on Appeal".		12-26711
09/04/2012	Notice of Appeal Documents	Filed Documents from District Court Clerk - Civil Cover Sheet (SEALED).
09/04/2012	Letter/Incoming	Filed Proper Person Letter Re: Childrens names listed in Motion to Stay and Removal of Attorney who is Suspended from the Nevada Bar.		12-27879
09/04/2012	Brief	Filed Civil Proper Person Appeal Statement.		12-27881
09/04/2012	Motion	Filed Proper Person Emergency Motion to Stay Proceedings and Enforcement in this Case Pending Appeal (Action Required Prior to October 15, 2012).		12-27886
09/11/2012	Motion	Filed Opposition to Emergency Motion to Stay Proceedings and Enforcement in this Case Pending Appeal.		12-28608
09/12/2012	Motion	Filed Proper Person Motion to Consolidate and Motion to Defer Filing Fee and Cost Bond.		12-28758
09/20/2012	Motion	Filed Supplement to Respondent's Opposition to "Emergency Motion to Stay Proceedings and Enforcement in this Case Pending Appeal".		12-29764
10/01/2012	Motion	Filed Request to Waive Deficiency in Reply Brief, or Alternatively, File Amended Reply Brief.		12-30993
10/22/2012	Order/Procedural	Filed Order. The clerk of this court is directed to administratively close the appeal pending in Docket No. 61626 and to transfer the September 5, 2012, notice of appeal filed under that docket number to Docket No. 61415. District Court: Record on Appeal due: 30 days. With regard to the bonds for costs on appeal, requests to vary the amount of the $500 bond required to cover costs on appeal must be made in the district court. Appellant's motion to defer payment of that bond is denied. We grant appellant's motion in part, for the limited purpose of allowing appellant to file an opening brief. Appellant: Opening Brief due: 50 days. Respondent need not file an answering brief unless directed to do so by this court. We conclude that a stay is not warranted and we therefore deny appellant's motion for a stay. Having considered the motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis, we conclude that it should be denied. Fn1[In light of this order, we deny as moot all requests for relief pending in Docket No. 61626.] Fn2[On September 12, 2012, appellant filed in Docket No. 61415 a motion seeking to consolidate Docket No. 61415 and 61626 and to defer payment of the filing fee and cost bond in Docket No. 61626. As we have directed that the appeal pending in Docket No. 61626 be administratively closed, this motion is denied as moot.] Fn4[The clerk of this court is directed to file appellant's reply, which was provisionally received in this court on September 20, 2012, and appellant's supplemental reply, which was provisionally received on September 26, 2012. As we have directed the filing of these documents, we deny as moot appellant's October 1, 2012, motion to waive deficiency in reply brief or to authorize the filings of an amended reply brief.] Fn5[The clerk of this court is directed to file appellant's motion, which was provisionally received in this court on September 26, 2012.] Fn6[With regard to the relief requested by appellant through a letter filed in this court on September 4, 2012. No action will be taken on appellant's letter.] Nos. 61415/61626		12-33333
10/22/2012	Motion	Filed Reply in Support of Emergency Motion to Stay Proceedings and Enforcement in this Case Pending Appeal.		12-29822
10/22/2012	Motion	Filed Supplemental Brief in Support of Emergency Motion to Stay Proceedings and Enforcement in this Case Pending Appeal.		12-30452
10/22/2012	Motion	Filed Proper Person Motion to Proceed In Forma Pauperis on Appeal.		12-30451
10/22/2012	Notice of Appeal Documents	Filed Notice of Appeal/Amended. (TRANSFERRED FROM DOCKET NO. 61626 PER ORDER FILED 10/22/12.)		12-33339
10/22/2012	Notice/Incoming	Filed Notice Regarding Non-Payment of Transcripts.		12-33468
11/08/2012	Record on Appeal Documents	Filed Record on Appeal Volumes 1-24 (Filed via FTP).		12-35334
11/08/2012	Case Status Update	Submitted for Decision.
12/05/2012	Notice/Incoming	Filed Notice of Change of Address of Appellant.		12-38350
12/05/2012	Transcript Request	Filed Certificate of No Transcript Request.		12-38353
12/14/2012	Notice/Incoming	Filed Proper Person (Corrected) Notice of Change of Address.		12-39649
12/14/2012	Brief	Filed Proper Person Appellant's Opening Brief.		12-39663
12/14/2012	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief CD-ROM included.		12-39668
12/19/2012	Motion	Filed Proper Person Motion "Renewed Emergency Motion to Stay Proceedings and Enforcement in This Case Pending Appeal".		12-40204
12/19/2012	Notice/Incoming	Filed Proper Person Notice Of California Determination Of Controlling Norwegian Child Support Order.		12-40211
12/19/2012	Notice/Incoming	Filed Proper Person Notice. Filed Proper Person Notice Of California Determination Of Controlling Norwegian Child Support Order.		12-40211
01/02/2013	Motion	Filed Opposition to Emergency Motion to Stay Proceedings and Enforcement in This Case Pending Appeal.		13-00122
01/07/2013	Motion	Filed Proper Person Reply Brief In Support Of Renewed Emergency Motion To Stay Proceedings and Enforcement In This Case Pending Appeal.		13-00611
01/16/2013	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Denying Emergency Motion for Stay.		13-01742
02/20/2013	Notice/Incoming	Filed Proper Person Notice of Kansas Order Confirming California's Determination of Controlling Child Support Order.		13-05258
03/28/2013	Motion	Filed Proper Person Motion to Consolidate. Nos. 61415/62797.		13-09187
04/17/2013	Notice/Incoming	Filed Correction to Statement of Fact in Support of Motion to Consolidate. Nos. 61415/62797.		13-11419
12/03/2013	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Granting Motion to Consolidate and Directing Transmission of Record. Proper person appellant has moved to consolidate these appeals. We grant it, and hereby consolidate these appeals. The clerk of this court shall file the copy of the motion to consolidate submitted in Docket No. 62797, which was provisionally received in this court on March 28, 2013. Record due from district court clerk: 30 days. Nos. 61415/62797.		13-36277
12/19/2013	Record on Appeal Documents	Filed Record on Appeal (PARTIAL) Vol 23. Nos.61415/62797.		13-38635
12/19/2013	Record on Appeal Documents	Filed Record on Appeal (PARTIAL) Vol. 24. Nos.61415/62797.		13-38636
12/19/2013	Record on Appeal Documents	Filed Record on Appeal (PARTIAL) Vol 25. Nos.61415/62797.		13-38638
12/20/2013	Case Status Update	Submitted for Decision. Nos.61415/62797.
08/19/2014	Notice/Incoming	Filed Respondent's Supplemental Authority For The Record. Nos. 61415/61797.		14-27224
01/06/2015	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Transferring to Court of Appeals. The clerk of this court is directed to assign this appeal to the Court of Appeals of Nevada for disposition. Nos. 61415/62797.		15-00447
01/06/2015	Case Status Update	Transferred from Supreme Court.
01/06/2015	Case Status Update	Submitted for Decision.
02/04/2015	Order/Procedural	Filed Order. Directing Response. Respondents: Response due: 30 days. Respondent's Response shall not exceed 30 pages plus the attorney's certificate. Respondent's Response may cite to either the record on appeal or any appendix filed with the response. Nos. 61415/62797.		15-900097
03/06/2015	Brief	Filed Response to Civil Proper Person Appeal Statement. Nos. 61415/62797		15-900235
03/31/2015	Notice/Incoming	Filed Proper Person Notice. Appellant's Reply Brief. Nos 61415/62797.		15-900334
05/21/2015	Notice/Incoming	Filed Proper Person Notice. . Notice of Change of Address. Nos. 61415/62797.		15-900550
06/01/2015	Notice/Incoming	Filed Notice. Respondent's Supplement. Nos. 61415/62797.		15-900590
06/09/2015	Notice/Incoming	Filed Proper Person Notice. Appellant's Notice of California Appellate Court Proceedings. Nos. 61415/62797.		15-900613
06/22/2015	Notice/Incoming	Filed Notice. Responent's Second Supplement. Nos. 61415/62797.		15-900670
12/29/2015	Order/Dispositional	Filed Order Affirming in Part, Dismissing in Part, Reversing in Part, and Remanding. "We affirm the district court's conclusion that the Nevada divorce decree was the controlling child support order under UIFSA; its decisions to not apply judicial estoppel, waiver, or prevention; and its determination that the awards of attorney fees made prior to Vaile II remained valid. And we reverse that portion of the district court's order calculating child support arrearages as well as the resulting penalties and interest based on the arrearages calculations and remand for further proceedings consistent with this order. We likewise reverse and remand with regard to the award of $57,483.38 in post-Vaile II attorney fees, but affirm the $20,000 award of attorney fees based on Vaile's failure to appear at a hearing. Finally, we dismiss Vaile's appeals for lack of jurisdiction to the extent he challenges the district court's contempt determinations and the imposition of sanctions based on those determinations." fn16[In light of this order, we deny as moot any remaining requests for relief pending in these consolidated appeals.] Court of Appeals-MG/JT/AS Nos. 61415/62797.
12/29/2015	Order/Dispositional	Filed Dispositional Order/Appeal. . Order Affirming in Part, Dismissing in Part, Reversing in Part, and Remanding"We affirm the district court’s conclusion that the Nevada divorce decree was the controlling child support order under UIFSA; its decisions to not apply judicial estoppel, waiver, or prevention; and its determination that the awards of attorney fees made prior to Vaile II remained valid. And we reverse that portion of the district court’s order calculating child support arrearages as well as the resulting penalties and interest based on the arrearages calculations and remand for further proceedings consistent with this order. We likewise reverse and remand with regard to the award of $57,483.38 in post-Vaile II attorney fees, but affirm the $20,000 award of attorney fees based on Vaile’s failure to appear at a hearing. Finally, we dismiss Vaile’s appeals for lack of jurisdiction to the extent he challenges the district court’s contempt determinations and the imposition of sanctions based on those determinations." fn16[In light of this order, we deny as moot any remaining requests for relief pending in these consolidated appeals.] Court of Appeals-MG/JT/AS Nos. 61415/62797.		15-901686
01/19/2016	Post-Judgment Petition	Filed Petition for Rehearing.		16-900039
01/19/2016	Filing Fee	Filing Fee Paid. Rehearing filing fee paid $150.00 from Robert Scotlund Vail. Check No. 1014.
04/14/2016	Post-Judgment Order/Dispositional	Order Granting Rehearing. in Part, Denying Rehearing in Part, and Affirming. Nos. 61415/62797.		16-900427
05/04/2016	Case Status Update	Transferred from Court of Appeals.
05/04/2016	Post-Judgment Petition	Filed Proper Person Petition for Review. Nos. 61415/62797.		16-14003
05/04/2016	Filing Fee	Returned Filing Fee. Check No. $150.00 returned to Robert Scotlund Vaile. (No filing fee required) Nos. 61415/62797.
05/04/2016	Case Status Update	Transferred to Supreme Court. Nos. 61415/62797
05/04/2016	Case Status Update	Case Closed. Nos. 61415/62797
07/21/2016	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Directing Answer to Petition for Review. Respondent's Answer due: 15 days. The remittitur is stayed pending resolution of the petition for review. Nos. 61415/62797.		16-22745
08/05/2016	Post-Judgment Petition	Filed Respondent's Answer to Petition for Review. Nos. 61415/62797.		16-24271
09/22/2016	Post-Judgment Order	Filed Order Granting Petition for Review. The petition for review is granted as to these two issues and this matter is submitted for decision on review without further briefing or oral argument. fn1[The Honorable Mark Gibbons, Justice, did not participate in the decision of this matter.] Nos. 61415/62797.		16-29504
09/22/2016	Case Status Update	Submitted for Decision.
12/05/2016	Order/Procedural	Filed Notice of Voluntary Disclosure. Nos. 61415/62797		16-37562
06/22/2017	Opinion/Dispositional	Filed Authored Opinion. "Affirmed." Before the Court En Banc. Author: Douglas, J. Majority: Douglas/Cherry/Gibbons/Pickering/Hardesty/Parraguirre/Stiglich. 133 Nev. Adv. Opn. No. 30. EN BANC Nos. 61415/62797		17-20696
07/10/2017	Motion	Filed Proper Person Appellant's Motion to Stay the Remittitur. Nos. 61415/62797.		17-22658
07/10/2017	Motion	Filed Respondent's Opposition to Appellant's "Motion to Stay the Remittitur." Nos. 61415/62797.		17-22796
08/09/2017	Order/Procedural	Filed Order to Stay Issuance of Remittitur. We hereby stay issuance of the remittitur until October 20, 2017. If the clerk of this court receives written notice by October 20, 2017, from the clerk of the United States Supreme Court that appellant has filed a petition for a writ of certiorari, the stay shall continue in effect until final disposition of the certiorari proceedings. If such notice is not received by October 20, 2017, the remittitur shall issue forthwith. Because the stay is initially in effect for a limited 120-day time period, we deny without prejudice respondent's request for a bond. Nos. 61415/62797.		17-26546
09/26/2017	Notice/Incoming	Filed Notice from US Supreme Court/Certiorari Filed. A petition for a writ of certiorari was filed on September 20, 2017 and placed on the docket as Case No.17-435. Nos. 61415/62797.		17-32695
10/30/2017	Notice/Incoming	Filed Respondent's Notice of U.S. Supreme Court Conference Decision and Request for Issuance of Remittitur. Nos. 61415/62797.		17-37020
11/06/2017	Notice/Incoming	Filed Notice from US Supreme Court/Certiorari Denied. The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied. Nos. 61415/62797.		17-37845
11/07/2017	Remittitur	Issued Remittitur.		17-38178
11/07/2017	Case Status Update	Remittitur Issued/Case Closed.
11/22/2017	Remittitur	Filed Remittitur. Received by District Court Clerk on November 14, 2017.		17-38178