Case Information: 87056
Short Caption:	VIRGIN VALLEY WATER DIST. VS. PARADISE CANYON, LLC	Court:	Supreme Court
		Related Case(s):	83947, 86480, 87661
Lower Court Case(s):	Clark Co. - Eighth Judicial District - A774539	Classification:	Civil Appeal - General - Other
Disqualifications:	Lee	Case Status:	Remittitur Issued/Case Closed
Replacement:	None for Justice Lee	Panel Assigned:	En Banc
To SP/Judge:	08/01/2023 / Mishel, Persi	SP Status:	Completed
Oral Argument:	01/15/2025 at 11:00 AM	Oral Argument Location:	Carson City
Submission Date:	01/15/2025	How Submitted:	After Oral Argument

+ Party Information
Role	Party Name	Represented By
Amicus Curiae	Moapa Valley Water District	Ethan Foster Gregory H. Morrison (Parsons Behle & Latimer/Reno)
Appellant	Virgin Valley Water District	Russell J Carr (Hutchison & Steffen, LLC/Reno) Joseph C. Reynolds (Hutchison & Steffen, LLC/Reno) Piers R. Tueller (Hutchison & Steffen, LLC/Las Vegas)
Respondent	Paradise Canyon, LLC	Matthew T. Kneeland (Sylvester & Polednak, Ltd.) Jeffrey R. Sylvester (Sylvester & Polednak, Ltd.)

Docket Entries
Date	Type	Description	Pending?	Document
07/31/2023	Filing Fee	Appeal Filing Fee due. (SC)
07/31/2023	Notice of Appeal Documents	Filed Notice of Appeal. Appeal docketed in the Supreme Court this day. (SC)		23-24465
07/31/2023	Other	Justice Patricia Lee disqualified from participation in this matter. Disqualification Reason: Law Firms. (SC)
07/31/2023	Notice/Outgoing	Issued Notice to Pay Supreme Court Filing Fee. No action will be taken on this matter until filing fee is paid. Due Date: 7 days. (SC)		23-24467
07/31/2023	Filing Fee	E-Payment $250.00 from Joseph C. Reynolds. (SC)
08/01/2023	Notice/Outgoing	Issued Notice of Referral to Settlement Program. This appeal may be assigned to the settlement program. Timelines for requesting transcripts and filing briefs are stayed. Docketing Statement mailed to counsel for appellant - due: 21 days. (SC)		23-24590
08/01/2023	Settlement Notice	Issued Notice: Assignment to Settlement Program. Issued Assignment Notice to NRAP 16 Settlement Program. Settlement Judge: Persi J. Mishel. (SC)		23-24700
08/22/2023	Docketing Statement	Filed Appellant's Docketing Statement. (SC)		23-27430
08/29/2023	Order/Procedural	Filed Notice of Non-Disqualifying Disclosure for Chief Justice Stiglich. (SC)		23-28281
09/01/2023	Settlement Program Report	Filed ECAR/Not Appropriate for Settlement Program. This case is not appropriate for mediation. (SC)		23-28826
09/05/2023	Settlement Order/Procedural	Filed Order Removing From Settlement Program/Briefing Reinstated. This appeal is removed from the settlement program. Appellant(s): 14 days transcript request; 90 days opening brief. (SC)		23-28898
09/18/2023	Transcript Request	Filed Appellant's Request for Transcript of Proceedings. 7/21/21; 8/4/21; 8/5/21 and 9/13/21. To Court Reporter: T Rhonda Aquilina, Reporter.(SC)		23-30533
09/18/2023	Transcript Request	Filed Appellant's Request for Transcript of Proceedings. (10-11-2021)To Court Reporter: Kimberly Estala, Recorder.(SC)		23-30534
09/18/2023	Transcript Request	Filed Appellant's Request for Transcript of Proceedings, 09-01-2023 To Court Reporter: Kimberly Farkas, Reporter.(SC)		23-30535
09/18/2023	Transcript Request	Filed Appellant's Request for Transcript of Proceedings. (04-20-2022,06-01-2022, 08-03-2022, 10-27-2022, 04-19-2023, 04-25-2023) To Court Reporter: Maria Garibay, Recorder. (SC)		23-30536
09/18/2023	Transcript Request	Filed Appellant's Request for Transcript of Proceedings. August 29, 2018 May 29, 2019,September 25, 2019,November 6, 2020,February 26, 2021,March 2, 2021,March 15, 2021, April 5, 2021,April 19, 2021, May 3, 2021, May 24, 2021. To Court Reporter: Peggy Isom, Reporter (SC)		23-30537
10/24/2023	Transcript	Filed Notice from Court Reporter. MARIA GARIBAY stating that the requested transcripts were delivered. Dates of transcripts: 04/20/2022;06/01/2022; 08/03/2022; 10/27/2022; 04/19/2023 & 04/25/2023. (SC)		23-34776
11/01/2023	Transcript	Filed Notice from Court Reporter. Peggy Isom, stating that the requested transcripts were delivered. Dates of transcripts:08-29-2018,05-29-2019- 11-06-2020- 02-26-2021, 03-15-2021, 04-05-2021- 05-03-2021 and 05-25-2021(SC)		23-35560
11/08/2023	Motion	Filed Appellant's Motion for 60-Day Extension of Time to File Opening Brief and Appendix (First Request)(SC)		23-36451
11/20/2023	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Granting Motion. Appellant shall have until February 2, 2024, to file and serve the opening brief and appendix. (SC)		23-37650
11/30/2023	Motion	Filed Respondent , Paradise Canyon, LLC's Motion to Consolidate Supreme Court Cases.(SC)		23-38819
12/06/2023	Motion	Filed Opposition to Respondent Paradise Canyon, LLC's Motion to Consolidate Appellate Docket No. 87056 with Docket No. 87661.(SC)		23-39623
12/12/2023	Motion	Filed Respondent's Reply in Support of Respondent, Paradise Canyon, LLC's Motion to Consolidate Supreme Court Cases.87056 and 87661(SC)		23-40166
12/15/2023	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Denying Motion. Respondents' motion to consolidate this appeal with the appeal in Docket No. 87661 is denied at this time. (SC)		23-40817
01/18/2024	Motion	Filed Motion for 45-day Extension of Time to File Opening Brief and Appendix (Second Request)(SC)		24-02007
01/26/2024	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Granting Motion. Appellant's opening brief and appendix due: March 18,2024. (SC)		24-03203
03/15/2024	Motion	Filed Appellant's Motion for 7-Day Extension of Time to File Opening Brief and Appendix (Third Request) (SC)		24-09341
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 1 (SC)		24-10185
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 2 (SC)		24-10186
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 3 (SC)		24-10187
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 4 (SC)		24-10188
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 5 (SC)		24-10195
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 6 (SC)		24-10191
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 7 (SC)		24-10208
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 8 (SC)		24-10193
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 9 (SC)		24-10194
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 10 (SC)		24-10196
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 11 (SC)		24-10197
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 12 (SC)		24-10198
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 13 (SC)		24-10201
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 14 (SC)		24-10203
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 15 (SC)		24-10206
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 16 (SC)		24-10210
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 17 (SC)		24-10218
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 18 (SC)		24-10219
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 19 (SC)		24-10220
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 20 (SC)		24-10222
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 21 (SC)		24-10232
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 22 (SC)		24-10226
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 23 (SC)		24-10228
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 24 (SC)		24-10231
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 25 (SC)		24-10233
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 26 (SC)		24-10234
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 27 (SC)		24-10235
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 28 (SC)		24-10236
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 29 (SC)		24-10238
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 30 (SC)		24-10239
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 31 (SC)		24-10241
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 32 (SC)		24-10243
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 33 (SC)		24-10246
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 34 (SC)		24-10250
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 35 (SC)		24-10252
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 36 (SC)		24-10254
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 37 (SC)		24-10257
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 38 (SC)		24-10262
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 39 (SC)		24-10264
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 40 (SC)		24-10366
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 41 (SC)		24-10267
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 42 (SC)		24-10270
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 43 (SC)		24-10271
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 44 (SC)		24-10276
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 45 (SC)		24-10280
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 46 (SC)		24-10282
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 47 (SC)		24-10283
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 48 (SC)		24-10285
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 49 (SC)		24-10288
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 50 (SC)		24-10291
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 51 (SC)		24-10294
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 52 (SC)		24-10296
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 53 (SC)		24-10298
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 54 (SC)		24-10304
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 55 (SC)		24-10310
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 56 (SC)		24-10313
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 57 (SC)		24-10317
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 58 (SC)		24-10320
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 59 (SC)		24-10323
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 60 (SC)		24-10324
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 61 (SC)		24-10325
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 62 (SC)		24-10363
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 63 (SC)		24-10200
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 64 (SC)		24-10199
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 65 (SC)		24-10207
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 66 (SC)		24-10202
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 67 (SC)		24-10204
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 68 (SC)		24-10205
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 69 (SC)		24-10209
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 70 (SC)		24-10217
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 71 (SC)		24-10227
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 72 (SC)		24-10211
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 73 (SC)		24-10230
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 74 (SC)		24-10223
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 75 (SC)		24-10221
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 76 (SC)		24-10237
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 77 (SC)		24-10240
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 78 (SC)		24-10242
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 79 (SC)		24-10244
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 80 (SC)		24-10247
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 81 (SC)		24-10249
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 82 (SC)		24-10251
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 83 (SC)		24-10253
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 84 (SC)		24-10256
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 85 (SC)		24-10258
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 86 (SC)		24-10260
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 87 (SC)		24-10261
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 88 (SC)		24-10365
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 89 (SC)		24-10265
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 90 (SC)		24-10293
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 91 (SC)		24-10295
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 92 (SC)		24-10297
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 93 (SC)		24-10299
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 94 (SC)		24-10301
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 95 (SC)		24-10302
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 96 (SC)		24-10303
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 97 (SC)		24-10307
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 98 (SC)		24-10308
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 99 (SC)		24-10309
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 100 (SC)		24-10311
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 101 (SC)		24-10314
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 102 (SC)		24-10316
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 103 (SC)		24-10328
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 104 (SC)		24-10329
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 105 (SC)		24-10330
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 106 (SC)		24-10332
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 107 (SC)		24-10336
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 108 (SC)		24-10337
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 109 (SC)		24-10338
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 110 (SC)		24-10339
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 111 (SC)		24-10340
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 112 (SC)		24-10341
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 113 (SC)		24-10343
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 114 (SC)		24-10344
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 115 (SC)		24-10345
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 116 (SC)		24-10347
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 117 (SC)		24-10348
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 118 (SC)		24-10349
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 119 (SC)		24-10350
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 120 (SC)		24-10352
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 121 (SC)		24-10355
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 122 (SC)		24-10356
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 123 (SC)		24-10357
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 124 (SC)		24-10360
03/22/2024	Appendix	Filed Appellant's Appendix Volume 125 (SC)		24-10361
03/25/2024	Brief	Filed Appellant's Opening Brief(SC)		24-10608
03/26/2024	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Granting Motion. The motion for an extension of time filed on March 15, 2024, is granted. The opening brief and appendix were filed on March 22 and 25, 2024. Respondent shall have until April 24, 2024, to file and serve the answering brief. (SC)		24-10764
03/27/2024	Motion	Filed Respondent's Motion for 90-Day Extension of Time to File Answering Brief and Appendix (First Request)(SC)		24-11007
04/01/2024	Motion	Filed Motion for Leave to File Brief of Amicus Curiae Moapa Valley Water District in Support of Appellant Virgin Valley Water District(REJECTED PER PHONE CALL)SC)
04/01/2024	Motion	Filed Motion for Leave to File Brief of Amicus Curiae Moapa Valley Water District in Support of Appellant Virgin Valley Water District. (BRIEF DETACHED AND FILED PER 5/3/24 ORDER). (SC)		24-11538
04/03/2024	Notice/Incoming	Filed Appellant's Notice of Change of Address(SC)		24-11804
04/08/2024	Motion	Filed Respondent's Opposition to Moapa Valley Water District's Motion to File An Amicus Curiae Brief(SC)		24-12328
04/09/2024	Motion	Filed Appellant's Motion for Full Stay Pending Appeal(Action Requested by: May 31, 2024)(SC)		24-12576
04/10/2024	Motion	Filed Respondent's Opposition to Motion for Full Stay Pending Appeal (SC)		24-12611
04/15/2024	Motion	Filed Amicus Curiae Reply to Paradise Canyon, LLC's Opposition to Moapa Valley Water District's Motion for Leave to File an Amicus Curiae Brief(SC)		24-13095
04/15/2024	Notice/Incoming	Filed Appellant's Notice of Errata and Motion to File Appellant's Appendix Amended Volume 51 (VOLUME 51 DETACHED AND FILED SEPERATELY PER 5/3/24 ORDER). (SC)		24-13135
04/16/2024	Motion	Filed Appellant's Reply in Support of Motion for Full Stay Pending Appeal(SC)		24-13323
05/03/2024	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Regarding Motions. Moapa Valley Water District (MVWD) has filed a motion for leave to file a brief of amicus curiae in support of appellant. Respondent opposes the motion and MVWD has replied. The motion is unnecessary. The clerk shall detach the amicus brief from the motion filed on April 1, 2024, and file it separately. Respondent's motion for an extension of time to file the answering brief and appendix is granted. Respondent shall have until July 23, 2024, to file and serve the answering brief and any appendix. Appellant's unopposed motion for leave to file an amended volume of the appendix is granted. The clerk shall detach amended volume 51 from the motion filed on April 15, 2024, and file it separately. (SC)		24-15604
05/03/2024	Brief	Filed Brief of Amicus Curiae Moapa Valley Water District in Support of Appellant Virgin Valley Water District. (FILED PER 5/3/24 ORDER). (SC)		24-15608
05/03/2024	Appendix	Filed Amended Appendix Volume 51. (FILED PER 5/3/24 ORDER). (SC)		24-15612
05/31/2024	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Denying Motion for Stay. Appellant has filed a motion for a full stay pending appeal. Respondent opposes the motion and appellant has replied. The motion is denied. (SC)		24-19123
06/14/2024	Brief	Filed Respondent, Paradise Canyon, LLC's Answering Brief(SC)		24-20862
06/28/2024	Motion	Filed Appellant's Motion for 45-day Extension of Time to File Reply Brief(First Request)(SC)		24-22638
07/16/2024	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Granting Motion. Appellant shall have until August 29, 2024, to file and serve the reply brief. (SC)		24-24717
08/29/2024	Brief	Filed Appellant's Reply Brief. (SC).		24-31319
08/30/2024	Case Status Update	Briefing Completed/To Screening. (SC)
12/02/2024	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Scheduling Oral Argument. This court has determined that oral argument would be of assistance in resolving the issues presented in this matter. Accordingly, oral argument is scheduled for January 15, 2025, at 11:00 a.m., in Carson City. The argument shall be limited to 30 minutes. (SC)		24-45744
01/02/2025	Notice/Outgoing	Issued Oral Argument Reminder Notice. (SC)		25-00114
01/15/2025	Case Status Update	Oral argument held this day. Case submitted for decision before Parraguirre/Bell/Stiglich. (SC)
04/24/2025	Opinion/Dispositional	Filed Authored Opinion. "Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded." Before: Parraguirre/Bell/Stiglich. Author: Stiglich, J. Majority: Parraguirre/Bell/Stiglich. 141 Nev. Adv. Opn. No. 19. A25-RP/LB/LS. (SC).		25-18287
05/06/2025	Post-Judgment Petition	Filed Respondent, Paradise Canyon, LLC's Petition for Rehearing(SC)		25-20350
05/06/2025	Filing Fee	Filing fee paid. E-Payment $150.00 from Matthew T. Kneeland(SC)
05/21/2025	Post-Judgment Order	Filed Order Denying Rehearing. "Rehearing Denied." NRAP 40(c). A25-RP/LB/LS (SC)		25-22595
05/29/2025	Post-Judgment Petition	Filed Respondent, Paradise Canyon, LLC's Petition for En Banc Reconsideration (SC)		25-23920
07/30/2025	Post-Judgment Order	Filed Order Denying En Banc Reconsideration. "En banc reconsideration denied." fn1 [The honorable Patricia Lee, Justice, did not participate in the decision in this matter.] EN BANC. (SC)		25-33296
08/20/2025	Remittitur	Issued Remittitur. (SC)		25-36512
08/20/2025	Case Status Update	Remittitur Issued/Case Closed.(SC)
09/09/2025	Remittitur	Filed Remittitur. Received by District Court Clerk on 8/22/25. (SC)		25-36512