Case Information: 69729
Short Caption:	IN RE: DISH NETWORK DERIVATIVE LITIG. C/W 69012	Court:	Supreme Court
Consolidated:	69012*, 69729	Related Case(s):	69012
Lower Court Case(s):	Clark Co. - Eighth Judicial District - A686775	Classification:	Civil Appeal - General - Other
Disqualifications:		Case Status:	Remittitur Issued/Case Closed
Replacement:		Panel Assigned:	En Banc
To SP/Judge:		SP Status:	Exempt
Oral Argument:		Oral Argument Location:
Submission Date:	06/05/2017	How Submitted:	After Oral Argument

+ Party Information
Role	Party Name	Represented By
Appellant	Jacksonville Police and Fire Pension Fund	Brian W. Boschee (Holley Driggs/Las Vegas) Adam D. Hollander (Bernstein Litowitz Berger & Grossman, LLP) Mark Lebovitch (Bernstein Litowitz Berger & Grossman, LLP) Debbie A. Leonard (McDonald Carano LLP/Reno) William N. Miller (Holley Driggs/Las Vegas) Jeffrey A. Silvestri (McDonald Carano LLP/Las Vegas) Jeroen Van Kwawegen (Bernstein Litowitz Berger & Grossman, LLP) Amanda C. Yen (McDonald Carano LLP/Las Vegas)
Reference Party	Dish Network Derivative Litigation
Respondent	Cantey M. Ergen	James C. Dugan (Willkie, Farr & Gallagher, LLP) Tariq Mundiya (Willkie, Farr & Gallagher, LLP) Joshua H. Reisman (Reisman Sorokac) Robert R. Warns, III (Reisman Sorokac)
Respondent	Carl E. Vogel	Brian T. Frawley (Sullivan & Cromwell, LLP/New York) Kirk B. Lenhard (Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck, LLP/Las Vegas) Jeffrey S. Rugg (Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck, LLP/Las Vegas) Debra L. Spinelli (Pisanelli Bice, PLLC)
Respondent	Charles M. Lillis	Robert S. Brady (Young, Conaway, Stargatt & Taylor, LLP) Robert J. Cassity (Holland & Hart LLP/Las Vegas) C. Barr Flinn (Young, Conaway, Stargatt & Taylor, LLP) David C. McBride (Young, Conaway, Stargatt & Taylor, LLP) J. Stephen Peek (Holland & Hart LLP/Las Vegas) Holly Stein Sollod (Holland & Hart, LLP/Denver)
Respondent	Charles W. Ergen	James C. Dugan (Willkie, Farr & Gallagher, LLP) Tariq Mundiya (Willkie, Farr & Gallagher, LLP) Joshua H. Reisman (Reisman Sorokac) Robert R. Warns, III (Reisman Sorokac)
Respondent	David K. Moskowitz	Brian T. Frawley (Sullivan & Cromwell, LLP/New York) Kirk B. Lenhard (Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck, LLP/Las Vegas) Jeffrey S. Rugg (Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck, LLP/Las Vegas)
Respondent	George R. Brokaw	Robert S. Brady (Young, Conaway, Stargatt & Taylor, LLP) Robert J. Cassity (Holland & Hart LLP/Las Vegas) C. Barr Flinn (Young, Conaway, Stargatt & Taylor, LLP) David C. McBride (Young, Conaway, Stargatt & Taylor, LLP) J. Stephen Peek (Holland & Hart LLP/Las Vegas) Holly Stein Sollod (Holland & Hart, LLP/Denver)
Respondent	James DeFranco	Brian T. Frawley (Sullivan & Cromwell, LLP/New York) Kirk B. Lenhard (Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck, LLP/Las Vegas) Jeffrey S. Rugg (Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck, LLP/Las Vegas)
Respondent	Kyle J. Kiser	Bruce R. Braun (Sidley Austin LLP/Chicago) James J. Pisanelli (Pisanelli Bice, PLLC) Debra L. Spinelli (Pisanelli Bice, PLLC)
Respondent	R. Stanton Dodge	Bruce R. Braun (Sidley Austin LLP/Chicago) James J. Pisanelli (Pisanelli Bice, PLLC) Debra L. Spinelli (Pisanelli Bice, PLLC)
Respondent	Thomas A. Cullen	Bruce R. Braun (Sidley Austin LLP/Chicago) James J. Pisanelli (Pisanelli Bice, PLLC) Debra L. Spinelli (Pisanelli Bice, PLLC)
Respondent	Tom A. Ortolf	Robert S. Brady (Young, Conaway, Stargatt & Taylor, LLP) Robert J. Cassity (Holland & Hart LLP/Las Vegas) C. Barr Flinn (Young, Conaway, Stargatt & Taylor, LLP) David C. McBride (Young, Conaway, Stargatt & Taylor, LLP) J. Stephen Peek (Holland & Hart LLP/Las Vegas) Holly Stein Sollod (Holland & Hart, LLP/Denver)

Docket Entries
Date	Type	Description	Pending?	Document
02/09/2016	Filing Fee	Filing Fee Paid. $250.00 from McDonald Carano Wilson. Check no. 25380.
02/09/2016	Notice of Appeal Documents	Filed Notice of Appeal. Appeal docketed in the Supreme Court this day. (Docketing statement mailed to counsel for appellant.)		16-04280
02/09/2016	Notice/Outgoing	Issued Notice of Referral to Settlement Program. This appeal may be assigned to the settlement program. Timelines for requesting transcripts and filing briefs are stayed.		16-04282
02/10/2016	Notice/Incoming	Filed Certificate of Service of Notice of Appeal and Notice of Referral to Settlement Program and Suspension of Rules.		16-04341
02/10/2016	Settlement Notice	Issued Notice: Exemption from Settlement Program. It has been determined that this appeal will not be assigned to the settlement program. Appellant(s) 15 days transcript request form; 120 days opening brief:		16-04413
02/18/2016	Motion	Filed Motion to Consolidate Appeals and Motion to Set Length of Consolidated Brief.		16-05194
02/18/2016	Notice/Incoming	Filed Appellant's NRAP 26.1 Disclosure Statement.		16-05209
02/18/2016	Notice/Incoming	Filed Certificate of Service of Motion to Consolidate Appeals and Motion to Set Length of Consolidated Brief and Appellant's NRAP 26.1 Disclosure Statement.		16-05316
02/26/2016	Docketing Statement	Filed Docketing Statement Civil Appeals.		16-06187
03/07/2016	Notice/Incoming	Filed Notice of No Opposition to Motion to Consolidate Appeals and Motion to Set Length of Consolidated Brief.		16-07132
03/07/2016	Notice/Incoming	Filed Certificate of Service of Notice of No Opposition to Motion to Consolidate Appeals and Motion to Set Length of Consolidate Brief.		16-07260
03/10/2016	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Granting Motion. We grant appellant's motion to consolidate these appeals for all appellate purposes. Opening Brief and Appendix (45 pages or 21,000 words) due: June 9, 2016. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-07671
05/26/2016	Motion	Filed Motion for Leave to Redact Portions of Appellant's Opening Brief and to Seal Portions of the Appendix. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16673
05/26/2016	Notice/Incoming	Filed Certificate of Service of 1) Motion for Leave to Redact Portions of Appellant's Opening Brief and to Seal Portions of the Appendix 2) Appendices Volumes 1 through 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16674
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 1 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16701
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 2 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16702
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 3 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16704
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 4 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16705
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 5 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16706
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 6 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16707
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 7 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16708
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 8 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16709
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 9 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16710
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 10 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16711
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 11 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16712
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 12 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16713
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 13 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16714
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 14 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16716
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 15 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16717
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 16 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16718
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 17 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16719
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 18 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16720
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 19 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16722
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 20 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16723
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 21 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16725
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 22 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16726
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 23 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16727
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 24 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16728
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 25 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16729
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 26 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16730
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 27 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16731
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 28 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16732
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 29 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16733
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 30 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16734
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 31 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16735
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 32 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16736
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 33 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16737
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 34 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16738
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 35 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16739
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 36 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16740
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 37 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16741
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 38 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16742
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 39 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16743
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 40 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16744
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 41 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16745
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 42 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16746
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 43 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16747
05/27/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Opening Brief Volume 44 of 44. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-16748
05/27/2016	Notice/Incoming	Filed Certificate of Service of Appellant's Opening Brief [Redacted].		16-16749
06/08/2016	Motion	Filed The SLC's Limited Opposition to Appellant's Motion for Leave to Redact Portions of Appellant's Opening Brief and to Seal Portions of the Appendix and Countermotion for Leave to Make Additional Redactions. Nos. 69012/69729. (DETACHED EXHIBIT C AND FILED SEPARATELY PER ORDER 10/20/16).		16-17764
06/08/2016	Notice/Incoming	Filed Certificate of Service. (The SLC's Limited Opposition to Appellant's Motion for Leave to Redact Portions of Appellant's Opening Brief and to Seal Portions of the Appendix and Countermotion for Leave to Make Additional Redactions.) Nos. 69012/69729.		16-17766
06/13/2016	Motion	Filed SLC's Motion for Leave to Exceed the Page and Type-Volume Limitations in the Answering Brief. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-18289
06/13/2016	Motion	Filed Stipulation to Extend Time for (1) The SLC to file the Answering Brief and (2) Jacksonville to file the Reply Brief. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-18290
06/13/2016	Notice/Incoming	Filed Certificate of Service of Motion for Leave to Exceed Page and Type-Volume Limitations in Answering Brief. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-18443
07/28/2016	Motion	Filed Motion for Leave to Redact Portions of Respondent Special Litigation Committee of Dish Network Corporation's Answering Brief and to Seal Portions of the Answering Appendix.		16-23578
08/17/2016	Order/Procedural	Filed Order. SLC also agrees to appellant's motion that referenced documents at pages JA007346-47, JA007356-57 and JA007468 of Volume 30, pages JA007502 and JA7535-43 of Volume 31, pages JA007769-72 of Volume 32 and page JA008245 of Volume 34 of the sealed portions of the Joint Appendix may be unsealed and disclosed publicly. The clerk of this court shall unseal the identified portions of the joint appendix, filed as "Appendix to Opening Brief." The clerk of this court shall file the redacted opening brief provisionally received on May 31, 2016, and shall file under seal the unredacted opening brief and sealed portions of the appendix to the opening brief, provisionally received in this court on May 27, 2016. The clerk of this court shall file SLC's redacted answering brief and appendix Volume I, provisionally received on July 28, 2016, and the sealed copies of the answering brief and Volume II of the appendix received on August 2, 2016. Pursuant to the parties' stipulation, appellant Jacksonville Police & Fire Pension Fund's reply brief shall be due September 26, 2016. fn1[We direct the clerk of this court to file SCL's "limited Opposition to Appellant's Motion for Leave to Redact Portions of Appellant's Opening Brief and to Seal Portions of the Appendix and Countermotion for Leave to Make Additional Redactions" with "Sealed Exhibit C," provisionally received on June 10, 2016.] Nos. 69012/69729.		16-25582
08/17/2016	Brief	Filed Appellant's Opening Brief (Redacted). Nos. 69012/69729. (BRIEF STRICKEN PER ORDER 10/20/16).
08/17/2016	Brief	Filed Appellant's Opening Brief (SEALED).
08/17/2016	Brief	Filed Special Litigation Committee of DISH Network Corporation's Answering Brief (Redacted) Nos. 69012/69729		16-25601
08/17/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Special Litigation Committee of DISH Network Corporation's Answering Brief (Volume I). Nos. 69012/69729.		16-25602
08/17/2016	Brief	Filed Special Litigation Committee of DISH Network Corporation's Answering Brief (SEALED). Nos. 69012/69729.
08/17/2016	Appendix	Filed Appendix to Special Litigation Committee of DISH Network Corporation's Answering Brief (Volume Il) (SEALED). Nos. 69012/69729
08/17/2016	Motion	Filed The SLC's Limited Opposition to Appellant's Motion for Leave to Redact Portions of Appellant's Opening Brief and to Seal Portions of the Appendix and Countermotion for Leave to Make Additional Redactions with SEALED Exhibit C. Nos. 69012/69729.
08/17/2016	Appendix	Filed SEALED Portions of Joint Appendix (CD-ROM included), vols. 7-13, 18-20, 23-39, and 41. (JA007346-47, JA007356-57 and JA007468 of Volume 30, pages JA007502 and JA7535-43 of Volume 31, pages JA007769-72 of Volume 32 and page JA008245 of Volume 34 unsealed and filed separately.) Nos. 69012/69729.
08/17/2016	Appendix	Filed Joint Appendix Portions - JA007346-47, JA007356-57 and JA007468 of Volume 30, pages JA007502 and JA7535-43 of Volume 31, pages JA007769-72 of Volume 32 and page JA008245 of Volume 33. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-25617
08/18/2016	Motion	Filed SLC's Motion Seeking Clarification of Order Dated August 17, 2016. Nos. 69012/69729. (DETACHED APPELLANT'S OPENING BRIEF (REDACTED) ATTACHED AS EXHIBIT A AND FILED SEPARATELY PER ORDER 10/20/16.)		16-25668
08/30/2016	Notice/Incoming	Filed Notice of Non-Opposition to the Motion Seeking Clarification of Order Dated August 17, 2016. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-26951
09/27/2016	Brief	Filed Appellant's Reply Brief. Nos. 69012/69729. (BRIEF SEALED PER ORDER 10/20/16).
09/27/2016	Case Status Update	Briefing Completed/To Screening. Nos. 69012/69729.
10/03/2016	Motion	Filed Motion for Leave to Redact Portions of Appellant's Reply Brief. Nos. 69012/69729. (DETACHED REPLY BRIEF AND FILED SEPARATELY PER ORDER 10/20/16).		16-30714
10/20/2016	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Granting Motions. The SLC asks this court to withdraw the redacted opening brief that was filed pursuant to this court's order on August 17, 2016, and to file in its stead the "fully redacted version" of the opening brief that was attached as Exhibit C to the SLC's "Limited Opposition to Appellant's Motion for Leave to Redact Portions of Appellant's Opening Brief and to Seal Portions of the Appendix and Countermotion for Leave to Make Additional Redactions with SEALED Exhibit C," filed June 8, 2016. We grant the SLC's unopposed motion. The clerk of this court shall strike the redacted opening brief filed August 17, 2016, and shall detach Exhibit A, the "fully redacted" brief, from SLC's motion for clarification and file it separately. The SLC has also filed an unopposed motion to file a redacted reply brief in place of the reply brief filed by appellant on September 27, 2016. We grant the motion. The clerk of this court shall seal the reply brief filed September 27, 2016. The clerk shall detach Exhibit A, the redacted reply brief, from the SLC's motion and file it separately. Nos. 69012/69729.		16-32818
10/20/2016	Brief	Filed Appellant's Opening Brief (Redacted). (DETACHED FROM SLC'S MOTION FILED 8/18/16 AND FILED SEPARATELY PER ORDER 10/20/16.)		16-32902
10/20/2016	Brief	Filed Reply Brief. (DETACHED FROM SLC'S MOTION FILED 10/3/16 AND FILED SEPARATELY PER ORDER 10/20/16.)		16-32912
02/21/2017	Brief	Filed Appellant's Notice of Supplemental Authority. Nos. 69012/69729.		17-05866
03/01/2017	Notice/Incoming	Filed Respondent's Response To Appellant's Notice Of Supplemental Authority. Nos. 69012/69729.		17-07083
03/02/2017	Notice/Incoming	Filed Amended Certificate of Service (Respondent's Response To Appellant's Notice Of Supplemental Authority).		17-07101
04/25/2017	Order/Clerk's	Filed Order Re: Scheduling of Oral Argument. This matter will be scheduled for oral argument on the next available calendar. Nos. 69012/69729.		17-13619
04/26/2017	Notice/Outgoing	Issued Notice Scheduling Oral Argument.Argument is scheduled for Monday, June 5, 2017, at 1:30 p.m. for 30 minutes in Las Vegas.		17-13840
05/22/2017	Notice/Outgoing	Issued Oral Argument Reminder Notice.		17-16978
06/05/2017	Case Status Update	Oral argument held this day. Case submitted for decision. Before the En Banc Court.
09/14/2017	Opinion/Dispositional	Filed Authored Opinion. "Affirmed in part and vacated in part." Before the Court En Banc. Author: Gibbons, J. Majority: Gibbons/Cherry/Douglas/Hardesty/Parraguirre/Stiglich. Pickering, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part. 133 Nev. Adv. Opn. No. 61. EN BANC Nos. 69012/69729		17-31069
10/02/2017	Post-Judgment Petition	Filed Appellant's Petition for Rehearing. Nos. 69012/69729.		17-33294
10/02/2017	Filing Fee	Filing fee paid. E-Payment $150.00 from Jeffrey A. Silvestri
10/09/2017	Order/Procedural	Filed Order Directing Answer to Petition for Rehearing. Respondent's Answer to Petition due: 15 days. Nos. 69012/69729.		17-34223
10/24/2017	Post-Judgment Petition	Filed Respondents George R. Brokaw, Charles M. Lillis and Tom A. Ortolf's Answer to Petition for Rehearing. Nos. 69012/69729.		17-36585
12/08/2017	Post-Judgment Order	Filed Order Denying Rehearing. "Rehearing Denied." NRAP 40(c). Nos. 69012/69729.		17-42325
01/02/2018	Remittitur	Issued Remittitur. Nos. 69012/69729		18-00041
01/02/2018	Case Status Update	Remittitur Issued/Case Closed. Nos. 69012/69729
01/19/2018	Remittitur	Filed Remittitur. Received by District Court Clerk on January 8, 2018.		18-00041